Aside from any other deterrent there is much that can be said or even mentioned about Islam and its current day identity crisis. As for this part in our ongoing series “Islam, Muslims, and America” so as not to confuse anyone, or certainly not to offend anyone it is important to clarify the verbage and its usage.
Identity crisis therefore is the disorientation or role confusion as a result of conflicting pressures and expectations within a given society, culture, or individual. Furthermore, identity crisis is the state of confusion occurring in a social structure (culture) or institution (group of people; corporation).
In part 3 of this series I closed a particular article with the notion that, “…without change growth cannot occur…and without growth, change cannot occur…” This is not confined to the individual human condition. In the year 1968 almost the entire world—in one way or another—was experiencing a cultural identity crisis. For some countries their experiences were earlier during the 1950s and others later, indeed occurring now.
In 1968 China experienced the Great Cultural Revolution; while at the exact same time America was experiencing a crisis that rumbled the ground the US Capitol building sat on. Moreover, shortly after the election of 1968 President Nixon literally had a small company of soldiers from the 82nd Airborne Division moved underneath the White House fearing for his own personal safety. Similar activities were occurring in the United Kingdom albeit referred to as “civil unrest.”
Lately there has been international uneasiness when it comes to the women’s head scarves. As we know from the experience in France the wearing of the head scarves was outlawed in schools. Moreover, the prime minister of Turkey literally sent his daughters to America for college insofar as they could continue to wear their head scarves. Interestingly in a survey conducted recently by the Pew Research Center and Princeton University showed that 70% of the American people indicated that Muslim women should be allowed to wear their head scarves.
This is but one example of a cultural identity crisis that Islam is experiencing. Many women who had never before worn head scarves, moreover, their mother’s who felt that it represented a backwardness that they had overcome and had left behind are now wearing them.
“People who had never recognized and seen themselves as Muslims had no choice but to see themselves as Muslims,”says Muzaffar Christi, director of the Migration Policy Institute at the New York University School of Law.
(Sources cited: Newsweek Magazine; Pew Research Center; Princeton University)
This concludes part 4 in the series “Islam, Muslims, and America.”
About J.Paul
Academia, Constitution, Musicianship, all around Caucasian male, straight, and professes Jesus Christ as the Lord of my life. Guitars -- Classical, Acoustic, A/E, Strat, a real bassist at heart, Les Paul Standard bass.
I find this post interesting, at least in the example of the use of women scarves. Before 9/11 women did not want to wear the scarf viewing it as something “backward” that they “left behind.” In that way, they blended in American culture at a time when such “blending in” really was not necessary (as in your first post, American feelings about Muslims was rather benign.
Yet after 9/11, when Americans were understandably nervous about Muslims, THAT is the time that suddenly the women, or at least their daughters, wore the scarves. In essence, they chose this time to declare their Muslim allegiance and yet decry the nervousness it entails at this stage of American history. Then they cry they are not allowed to “blend in” when before they were already blending in without the scarves.
Like most Americans, I say wear the scarves. It is your “badge of membership” to use N.T. Wright’s terms. It is your tag that you are “special” to your God. But you can’t be “special’ and “ordinary” at the same time. “Ordinary” blends in. “Special’ does not. You can’t have it both ways.
LikeLike
Hey JDsg,
I don’t know which comment you are referring too. Everything I’ve received is up and posted. I have been looking forward to hearing from you with respect to my response to your original comment. Can you resend? As always…cheers!
OMC
LikeLike
For some reason, my response has not shown up on your blog, although WordPress says that it’s there. Have you read it, by chance?
LikeLike
JDsg:
Thank you for your rather impassioned response. I feel either that one, you are misunderstanding the entire notion behind “Identity” and two, the natural process of cultural evolution.
Hence my qualifying identifier in paragraph four regarding growth. If one culture or subsequent society does not grow the inevitability of that culture’s demise is certain.
Are you stating in your position that Islam and, or Islamic standards have not been changing? Are you implying that “all is well in Islam”? From the Muslim perspective now, are you suggesting that there IS NOT any discord or various modifications going on within the faith?
Here at The Thinker we do have rules of conduct and language is perhaps the biggest part of those rules. Though I do not find anything offensive in your response, please realize that everyone who visits this site is not scholarly and do not understand academic debate.
As scholars, moreover as writers and statesmen, we have a responsibility to our readership to present material in an orderly fashion and that is understandable. Personally, I do NOT feel that it is in good or proper form to bring up partial quotes from unknown people at an unknown time as I feel that this practice serves to Invalidate your points.
Furthermore I have a very basic question for you AND anyone else who wants to weith-in:
Why would a non-Muslim have problems with their identity? Why is it that Europeans in particular are having an identity crisis?
With the greatest of respect to you, your premise followed by the example is really quite confusing.
Great to hear from you, Cheers!
OMC
LikeLike
Actually, I’d say that the real identity crisis is being suffered by non-Muslims in general and Europeans in particular. For example:
LikeLike